THE STUDY OF HISTORY AND COMMUNITY IDENTITY
THROUGH MURALS
with a wall or ceiling surface
2mural n (1916): a mural work of art (as a painting
EDU 553
Professor David Stoloff
by
Teresa MaturinoyBuschman
December 1999
Lesson One: What are Murals and What do they have to do with History?
This lesson serves as an introduction to the unit. Students develop a definition of murals based on Internet research and begin to reflect on the use of murals to learn about history.
Lesson Two: How are murals made?
In this lesson students research and develop their own outline on the general steps taken to develop a mural project from beginning to end. They also develop their own vocabulary list to be shared amongst classmates and used throughout this unit.
Lesson Three: Murals and Muralists around the World
Students use the Internet to search for murals from around the world. They also learn about the Diego Rivera, a Mexican muralist known internationally for his mural work. The students’ final assignment is to research an international children’s mural project to promote peace.
Lesson Four: Murals and Muralists in the United States
Grant Wood and his mural project at the Iowa State University are the focus of this lesson. In this lesson students learn about "regionalism" as an art movement in the U.S as they study Wood’s mural project. Students also research murals throughout the U.S.
Lesson Five: Murals and Muralists in the United States -- What We Have Learned
In this lesson students use the information gathered from the assignment in Lesson Four to prepare a PowerPoint (or other multimedia) presentation. See Note in lesson if there is no access to multimedia software.
Lesson Six: A Mural Look at History and Community Identity
This lesson takes a deeper look at interpreting history and community identity through murals by focusing on one single mural.
Lesson Seven: Can we Afford to Create Our Own Mural?
Here students learn about presenting proposals and budgets. They use spreadsheet software, such as Excel, to work with budgets.
Lesson Eight: Creating a Class Mural: Content and Research
This lesson gives students an opportunity to think about their own community identity and how they would represent the history of their community for future generations.
Lesson Nine: Creating a Class Mural: Art and Painting
This lesson should be done with the assistance and advice of an art instructor, since students devote their time to painting their final murals.
Lesson Ten: School Name 5th graders Make History…Murals!
This lesson wraps-up the Unit with a festive atmosphere.
Students display their murals with brief written descriptions and invite
others to come in and enjoy them.
This curricular unit is designed to help students learn about murals as an art form that allows people to express and others to learn about community identity and history. In this unit students will learn about history through murals. They will also have an opportunity to see themselves as a part of history and to reflect on their own cultural identity within their community. An underlying goal of this unit is to help students think critically about history, how it is constructed, presented, and interpreted In addition, students will gain an understanding of the process involved in developing a mural project from beginning to end.
Grade Level: 5th and above
This unit is intended for students in grades 5 and above. A few modifications in content and assignment requirements would make it feasible for use with grade 4.
Assumptions
An underlying assumption of this unit is that students have a basic knowledge of and experience with the use of computers. It is assumed that students have access to computers equipped with word-processing and spreadsheet software, as well as access to the Internet. It is also assumed that students have little or no knowledge of murals. Finally, it is assumed the teacher leading the unit will guide students on the proper use of the Internet and information obtained from it.
Topics Covered
In completing this unit students should be able to:
The entire unit will be assessed based on the content in a Unit Portfolio. The Portfolio will consist of assignments completed by the student independently or with a group and the teacher’s evaluation for each assignment. Each lesson includes an assessment tool or provides assessment options.
Teachers should require students to cite all Internet references used for their assignments.
About On-line Sites
Internet sites suggested throughout the Unit were chosen based on their relevance to the assignments and lessons, as well as their appropriateness for use in an educational setting. Teachers are expected to review the each site prior to sharing them with their students.
Some sites are used for more than one lesson, and a brief
description is provided when deemed necessary or helpful.
Lesson One
What are Murals and What do they have to do with History?
color images of murals
access to the Internet
Procedure
Part 1:
Initiate the lesson by sharing images of murals from different artists and different regions of the U.S. and the world. This can be done by preparing color photocopies on transparencies, developing projector slides, using multimedia presentation software, or displaying posters and books with the images of murals. Obviously, the larger and more vivid the image, the more it will attract the students’ attention and stimulate their curiosity. Let the students know that they are observing images of murals.
Bring the class together by asking them a few questions:
Have students work in groups of 2 or 3 to begin their research of murals on the Internet.
The following sites have been selected to help students begin their search and complete their assignment.
Art is the Heart of the City - Public Art Mural Project, Charlotte NC, a joint project completed with the help of twenty-two 11th and 12th grade students
Mural Art - California, includes murals about different ethnic groups in the community
KIDS' GUERNICA, an international children’s project promoting the message of peace
Bob Jenny's Murals and Paintings, an artist’s mural work for military medical facilities
Mural Routes, a site designed to promote and facilitate the creation of public art murals
Of the five sites listed above, Mural Routes provides the most detailed information about how to create a mural.
Assignment
The students’ goals for this assignment are to:
Click here to view an example assessment tool.
How are murals made?
Mr. Principal has asked our class to make a Mural!
Objectives
large pieces of paper
markers of different colors
vocabulary list
access to the Internet
Procedure
Part 1:
In the first half of this lesson the students develop a plan on how to create a mural. Initiate the lesson by developing a scenario for the students. For example, tell the students that the principal has asked the class to develop a mural for the main hallway. Unless it seems necessary, try not to provide any information as to how or where the mural will be developed. Part of the assignment is to have students come up with their own ideas for such questions.
Have students work in small groups with large paper and markers of different colors. They are to devise an outline of a plan of what they would do to create a mural and make a list of the items and resources they would need. Wrap-up this part of the lesson by having each group share their outlined poster plan. Highlight significant comments made, and write them on the board as the students present their outlines.
Part 2:
Students may choose to work in pairs or individually to research how murals are created. After browsing the selected sites, the students will choose one to help them complete their assignment.
Yale Peabody Museum: The Mural provides a detailed description about one of the largest mural projects in the world. This mural on reptiles is located in New Haven, CT.
Murals Designed by Grant Wood provides a description of Grant Wood’s mural project at Iowa State University.
Xavier Cortada Gallery of Paintings and Community Murals, a site about the art work of a Cuban American artist based in Miami, Florida
Mural Routes, a site designed to promote and facilitate the creation of public art murals
Art is the Heart of the City - Public Art Mural Project, Charlotte NC, a joint project completed with the help of twenty-two 11th and 12th grade students
Assignment
The students’ goals for this assignment are:
Click here to view an example assessment tool.
Murals and Muralists around the World
Objectives
computers with access to the Internet
pens or pencils
writing paper
Procedure
Part 1:
For the first part of the lesson students are to choose a particular part of the world (continent, country, region) about which they would like to find murals. Students are to look for murals that share something about the region they have chosen. Murals that represent historical or social information are of particular interest for the assignment. Note: there are many sites on commercial murals and students should be alerted that these are not the murals that are being studied. This lesson provides an opportunity to improve research skills. Prior to the search, teachers should review sites pertinent to the assignment, possible phrases or topics for their search, and evaluating the reliability of information obtain through the Internet.
Part 2:
The Mexican muralist Diego Rivera is perhaps one of the most prominent international muralists. A brief presentation on Rivera and his murals will serve students as an example of murals that represent history, and students will also learn about the culture of Mexico. It should also be noted that Rivera painted well-known murals in the United States. The following sites are helpful for this part of the lesson.
PHOTO STRIP 19 - Mexico Murals, six images of murals by Mexican muralists
Irish Republican Murals, three images of sociopolitical murals from Ireland
Pembroke Heritage Murals-Canada, image and description of mural project in the city of Pembroke
Nicaraguan Mural Project, one mural image and brief description of project
SCARBOROUGH ARTS. COM -- Canada, a site supported by the Scarborough Art Council has links to mural projects in the Scarborough, Canada
Latin
American Murals, mural images created by students in a World Studies
class (school and grade not noted)
Assignment
Students will browse the KID’S GUERNICA site on the Web for this assignment. KID’S GUERNICA is an international project organized by the ART JAPAN NETWORK in 1995. The project attempts to reach children from around the world, via the Internet, to paint a message of peace. They will choose one of the murals on the site on which to develop a report. Students may choose one of two ways to report their findings.
Choice 1: Students will work in groups of 2 or 3 to complete a short picture book for children in grades 1 to 3. The book must include:
Assessment
An evaluation sheet such as the ones provided for Lessons One and Two
may be developed for this assignment. Another assessment option is to give
each assignment a letter grade based on specific criteria. An explanation
of what determines each grade should be handed out to the students along
with the assignment. The assignments may also be given a pass/fail assessment,
which will count for a grade increase or decrease when evaluating the final
portfolio.
Murals and Muralists in the United States
American Regionalism
Objectives
access to the Internet
pen/pencils and paper
Research Fact Sheet (teacher designed)
Procedure
Although it is not a mural, initiating the lesson with Grant Wood’s American Gothic (this site includes other paintings and photographs) painting will give students a recognizable point of reference for this lesson (assuming most students recognize the image). Introduce Grant Wood as an American artist who, along with other artists, believed people should paint what "they know best" or the world around them. He was part of an art movement known as regionalism. Within the time of the lesson, students are to complete a Research Fact Sheet on Murals Designed by Grant Wood, a site dedicated to Wood’s mural project at the Iowa State University.
Assignment
This assignment is based on a hypothetical scenario. The (Local) Museum wants to hire a team of people for their most important department: Mural Art & History. They will hire a team based on a presentation they give on murals and history in the U.S. This assignment requires students to work in groups of 2 or 3. Students are to search the following sites on murals in the U.S. They are to gather important facts and information about a mural or mural project in one particular state, city, or region of the U.S. to prepare for their presentation. Students will need to have their information ready and organized (in note form) for Lesson Five.
City of Murals: Steubenville, Ohio
Murals of Pine Bluff, Arkansas
Murals of Humboldt County, California
The Murals of Cape Girardeau County, Missouri
Dan Fontes: Oakland Art, California
Cincinnati Museum Center Murals: Ohio
Art is the Heart of the City: Charlotte, North Carolina
Cuban American Artist: Miami, Florida
Assessment
The Fact sheet will serve as an assessment tool. Again
a pass/fail or point system may be established to assess the Fact sheet.
There will be no assessment on the out-of-class assignment, although work
should be included in the portfolio. Lack of effort on the assignment will
be reflected when completing the assignment in Lesson Five.
Lesson Five
Murals and Muralists in the United States
What We Have Learned
Objectives
computers equipped with multimedia software (PowerPoint)
Procedure
This lesson is an extension of Lesson Four. It involves helping students put together a multimedia presentation about their U.S. mural research and findings. The presentation should include:
Assignment
The final assignment is to complete the presentations and share them with the class. Student presentations may be completed during social studies and language arts.
A checklist should be designed to evaluate the presentation, noting
all parts that should be included in it. The checklist may be distributed
to the class to allow for peer evaluations. The teacher’s comments and
the peers’ checklists should be included in the portfolio.
Lesson Six
access to the Internet
Procedure
This lesson is designed to help students refocus on and synthesize the work they have been doing for the last five lessons. The questions posed in Lesson One will be revisited and used to analyze Murals from Los Angeles. This site is used to show how murals reflect the identity and history of a region or community. The murals on this site have been chosen because they are archetypal examples of murals that reflect history and identity and because the author of this unit is familiar with their content. Teachers may use this site but are encouraged to use one from a region, culture, or group of people with which they are familiar.
Assignment
The only assignment for this lesson is participation by asking questions
or making comments during the lesson. The teacher should comment on each
student’s participation by noting it in his or her individual portfolio.
Lesson Seven
Can we Afford to Create Our Own Mural?
Objectives
list of materials and prices (teacher created)
computers equipped with Excel or other spreadsheet software
proposal application
Procedure
Initiate the lesson by telling students they have an opportunity to create their own mural. Money, however, is a realistic and necessary component in completing a mural. People designing a mural must make choices on the types and quantities of materials they use based on the funds available to them.
Scenario: The town council has allocated a $100 budget for a mural project. In order to obtain the funds the students need to complete a proposal, which includes an application, a budget, and a narrative. In this case, each application returned complete will receive the $100 to complete a mural project.
Students will use Excel to develop a budget representing fund allocations for different quantities of various types of materials needed to create a mural. After going through one budget example on Excel with the entire class, students are to develop two more budgets on their own. One of the budgets will be used for the application and narrative and will be handed in as a complete proposal.
Wrap-up the lesson by handing out the application forms and explaining that the narrative is a written document that explains the nature of the project and how the different items needed to complete the project will be used.
Assignment
Students will hand in a complete proposal, which includes
a cover page, the application, the spreadsheet printout of the budget,
and the narrative (preparing and presenting one ahead of time may be useful).
Assessment
Evaluate the assignment as an actual proposal and like
someone who would be funding the project. In addition, critique mathematical,
grammar, and presentation errors. Comment on how any error may affect the
opportunity of the proposal being approved. The students’ proposals will
be returned with comments for revisions. Students should turn in revised
proposals for a final assignment grade.
Creating a Class Mural: Content and Research
Objectives
pencils
markers
paper
Procedure
Initiate the lesson by telling students that today they will create history! Yes, they will create a mural that will be used by fifth grade students one hundred years from now. The mural will be the future students’ only source from which to learn about the history, the values, the culture, and identity of the current people and community. What do you (the students) want them to know? How do you want them to think about you and your families? How will they know what is important to you? (Defining community may a be an additional component of this lesson.)
Students will work in groups of 3 or 4 to complete the following tasks:
Students are to search the web to learn about important aspects of their community. They are to include at least two well-known establishments from their community, whether or not they are found on the Web, in their final mural project.
Assessment
No formal assessment is suggested for Lessons Eight and
Nine. All relevant materials completed for these lessons should be included
in the portfolio. The final mural product will reflect the quality and
effort of work completed for Lessons Eight and Nine.
Lesson Nine
Art: Painting Our Mural
Objectives
art materials to paint and draw
art paper
The help of the school art teacher should be sought for this lesson
Procedure and Assignment
The final lessons of this unit allow the students to complete their own murals. Initiate the lesson by reviewing some of the murals viewed in the previous lessons. In conjunction with the art teacher, share with students how color or technique can be used to convey an idea, message, or mood. For example, show how Rivera’s vibrant colors in his murals can remind someone of the bright colors often used in Mexican pottery, textiles, or homes. These are aspects of art students should keep in mind while thinking about the messages they will convey in their mural.
Each group of students will complete a mural based on the materials
available. Remaining consistent with the characteristic and definition
of a mural, the students’ murals should be completed on a large piece of
paper, perhaps no smaller than 20 sq. ft. Another option is to combine
the student sketches and complete a single class mural, perhaps no smaller
than 40 sq. ft.
School Name 5th graders Make History…Murals!
The final lesson involves wrapping up the unit with a historical mural fest. Have students display their murals throughout the classroom. Have them place a brief description of the name of their mural, what it represents, and their names besides their mural as is done with art in museums. Encourage students to bring music and food that they feel represents the images and message in their murals. Invite other classrooms and staff to come enjoy the murals.
Other Options
Wrap-up the unit by allowing students to debrief, while they enjoy
refreshments. The final written assignment is to complete a reflective
questionnaire designed by the teacher.
Links to this document
Lesson 1: Example
Assessment Tool
| Assignments | Poor | Fair | Good | Outstanding |
| Student(s) completed objective
1:
they provided a clear definition of a mural in their own words. |
||||
| Student(s) completed objective
2:
they supported their definition with clear examples. |
||||
| Student(s) completed objective
3:
their interpretation of the selected mural is logical and supported by evidence in the image. |
||||
| Students present the assignment in a clear and logical format. | ||||
| Student(s) use proper grammar, punctuation, and spelling. | ||||
| Extra Credit | ||||
| Student(s) included comments/evidence that exceeded assignment requirements. | ||||
Lesson 2: Example Assessment
tool
| Assignment | Points
Possible |
Points
Awarded |
| OUTLINE | ||
| Outline includes expected general
steps and
those reviewed in class. |
|
|
| Outline is presented in a logical sequence. |
|
|
| Outline is presented in an acceptable academic format. |
|
|
| Outline shows proper grammar, spelling, and punctuation |
|
|
| Extra credit: |
|
|
| VOCABULARY | ||
| Includes 10 words with definitions |
|
|
| All 10 words are spelled correctly |
|
| Example Budget for a Mural | ||||||
|
|
|
|
||||
| Canvas | $ 3.35 |
|
$ 20.10 | Canvas | $3.35/yd. | |
| red paint | $ 2.67 |
|
$ 8.01 | Paint: $/qt. | ||
| blue paint | $ 2.20 |
|
$ 11.00 | red | $ 2.67 | |
| white paint | $ 1.98 |
|
$ 13.86 | blue | $ 2.20 | |
| $ - | yellow | $ 2.20 | ||||
| basic brushes | $ 5.35 |
|
$ 10.70 | white | $ 1.98 | |
| Rivera premium | $ 7.75 |
|
$ 7.75 | black | $ 2.01 | |
| $ - | ||||||
| rulers | $ 0.99 |
|
$ 4.95 | Brushes: | ||
| compass | $ 3.75 |
|
$ 3.75 | basic | $ 5.35 | |
| $ - | Just as good | $ 6.80 | ||||
| cleaning kit | $ 33.89 |
|
$ 33.89 | Rivera premium | $ 7.75 | |
| Measuring Tools: | ||||||
| Subtotal* | $ 114.01 | ruler | $ 0.99 | |||
| Sales tax (6%)* | $ 6.84 | yard stick | $ 1.68 | |||
| Total* | $ 120.85 | tape | $ 2.56 | |||
| compass | $ 3.75 | |||||
| Cleaning supplies: | ||||||
| one kit | $ 33.89 | |||||
*denotes where Excel functions were used for calculations
Lesson 7: Sample Application
Form
Proposal Application
A. Project
Name of Project Date submitted
B. Applicant Information
Name of Applicant 1 phone number
Name of Applicant 2 phone number
Name of Applicant 3 phone number
Address for project correspondence (P.O. or street name and number,
city, and zip code)
Expected commencement date Expected completion date
Brief Description of Project:
$
Expected Cost
Application includes a budget sheet (spreadsheet)
Application includes a project and budget narrative